Skip to content
SportsBookISH
Start free
Free · save favorites, get the top edges emailed daily, set custom alerts (Elite).Sign up free →
← MLB
game
Sign up free
⚾

Toronto vs New York Y

May 19, 2026 at 7:05 PM
KXMLBGAME-26MAY191905TORNYY
Force refresh (Elite)
Bet Tracker — log this bet + score your edge identification over time.Sign up
LinesKalshi vs book consensus (free shows 5 of N books)
New York Y
56.5%
Bid 56.0¢ · Ask 57.0¢ · Last 57.0¢
Books median 55.4% (11 books, 54.4%–56.3%)Best book betrivers -134 (54.4%)
Buy edge vs median -1.10%· 🔒 net-of-feevs best book -2.14%
BetMGM-140
BetOnline-131
betrivers-134
betus-131
Bovada-139
Caesars 🔒-135DraftKings 🔒-137fanatics 🔒-140FanDuel 🔒-142lowvig 🔒-131mybookie 🔒-135Sign up free →
Toronto
44.5%
Bid 44.0¢ · Ask 45.0¢ · Last 45.0¢
Books median 44.6% (11 books, 43.7%–45.6%)Best book FanDuel +120 (43.7%)
Buy edge vs median +0.10%· 🔒 net-of-feevs best book -0.85%
BetMGM+115
BetOnline+119
betrivers+108
betus+119
Bovada+116
Caesars 🔒+115DraftKings 🔒+114fanatics 🔒+115FanDuel 🔒+120lowvig 🔒+119mybookie 🔒+115Sign up free →
Spread · 11 booksConsensus line: -1.5🔒 6 books locked — Sign up free to unlock
TeamDraftKingsFanDuelBetMGMCaesarsbetriversBetOnline🔒betus🔒Bovada🔒fanatics🔒lowvig🔒mybookie🔒
New York Y
-1.5
+144
-1.5
+140
-1.5
+150
-1.5
+150
-1.5
+155
-1.5
+153
-1.5
+152
-1.5
+150
-1.5
+150
-1.5
+154
-1.5
+147
Toronto
+1.5
-175
+1.5
-170
+1.5
-185
+1.5
-178
+1.5
-195
+1.5
-175
+1.5
-175
+1.5
-175
+1.5
-180
+1.5
-175
+1.5
-181
Total · 11 books · 2 lines🔒 6 books locked — Sign up free to unlock
LineSideDraftKingsFanDuelBetMGMCaesarsbetriversBetOnline🔒betus🔒Bovada🔒fanatics🔒lowvig🔒mybookie🔒
8.5Over—-124-120-125—-123-125-125—-121-122
Under—+102+100+105—+103+105+105—+106+100
9Over+100———+100———+100——
Under-120———-122———-120——
Don't miss the next edge. Sign up free to save preferences and get the daily top edges by email. Elite ($39) sends email + SMS the moment Kalshi moves ≥3% in 15 min on any market.

Toronto vs New York Y odds — FAQ

What are the best odds for Toronto vs New York Y?
New York Y currently has the largest edge — Kalshi is priced -1.1 percentage points different from the sportsbook consensus. Compare per-book pricing in the table above; longest American prices are highlighted.
When is Toronto vs New York Y?
Toronto vs New York Y starts at Tue, 19 May 2026 19:05:00 GMT. Markets close at kickoff/tip-off on most books; Kalshi typically keeps trading until the event resolves.
Where can I get the best price on Toronto vs New York Y?
The "Best book" column above identifies the sportsbook offering the longest American price per side. We track 11 books on this matchup; subscribe to Pro for full per-book pricing across all MLB markets.
Is Toronto vs New York Y on Kalshi?
Yes — Kalshi lists MLB game markets as event contracts. You buy YES or NO at the listed price; contracts settle at $1 or $0 when the game ends.